Elf on the Shelf Ideas with Stuffed Animals

18 Elf on the Shelf ideas that use stuffed animals. From simple scenes like "Story Time Reading" to more elaborate ones like "Paper Bag Animal Race", here's every idea from our catalog that calls for stuffed animals.

18 ideas Use the generator instead →
Living Room ●○○○○

Story Time Reading

Gather a pile of plush toys on the couch around the elf, who is holding an open Christmas book. Position him as if mid-sentence.

Ages 3–10 Pet-safe 0
Bedroom ●●○○○

First Aid Bandaging

Wrap a bandage around a stuffed animal or doll and pose the elf as the doctor holding a mini first aid kit. Add a clipboard with a tiny chart.

Ages 3–10 Pet-safe 0
Bedroom ●●○○○

Stuffed Animal Sleepover

Elf surrounded by or sleeping with collection of stuffed animals.

Ages 3–10 Pet-safe 0
Bedroom ●●○○○

Hiding in Stuffed Animals

Bury elf among pile of stuffed animals as hiding spot.

Ages 3–10 Pet-safe 0
Living Room ●●○○○

Storybook Reader

Prop open Christmas book under tree; elf holds it with stuffed animals listening.

Ages 3–10 Pet-safe 0
Bedroom ●●○○○

Hugging Soft Toy

Elf with arms wrapped around stuffed animal or plush toy.

Ages 3–10 Pet-safe 0
Living Room ●●○○○

Toy Tea Party Host

Toy dishes, cups, stuffed animals around elf as tea party.

Ages 3–10 Pet-safe 0
Bedroom ●●○○○

Teddy Bear Story Time

Elf with book surrounded by teddy bears telling a story.

Ages 3–10 Pet-safe 0
Living Room ●●○○○

Plush Circle Story Time

Arrange elf surrounded by plush toys with book for story time setup.

Ages 3–10 Pet-safe 0
Bedroom ●●○○○

Stuffed Toy Peek-a-Boo

Elf is hidden among child's collection of plush toys.

Ages 3–10 Pet-safe 0
Living Room ●●●○○

Mini Disco Party

Set up a small flashlight or battery-operated color lights on a plate and pose the elf in the middle like he's dancing. Add a few plush toys as partygoers.

Ages 3–10 Pet-safe 0
Bathroom ●●●○○

Elf Bubble Bath

Fill the tub with an inch of water and float white balloons as giant bubbles. Pose the elf and a plush toy relaxing among them.

Ages 3–10 Pet-safe 0
Bedroom ●●●○○

Elf Playing School

Line up stuffed animals facing a mini whiteboard with a lesson written on it. Pose the elf at the front as the teacher with a pointer.

Ages 3–10 Pet-safe 0
Bedroom ●●●○○

Elf Teacher

Elf positioned as classroom teacher with stuffed animals as students.

Ages 3–10 Pet-safe 0
Living Room ●●●○○

Ankshiosis Stuffed Animal Medics

The elf lies diagnosed with mock Christmas anxiety, surrounded by stuffed animal medical staff.

Ages 3–10 Pet-safe 0
Living Room ●●●○○

Stuffed Animal Poker Game

Arrange stuffed animals around a small table with cards dealt and chocolate coins.

Ages 3–10 Not pet-safe 0
Living Room ●●●○○

Stuffed Animal Pile Hide

Hide the elf among a pile of stuffed animals and toys.

Ages 3–10 Pet-safe 0
Kitchen ●●●●○

Paper Bag Animal Race

Place elf in paper bag with stuffed animals in other bags, create race line.

Ages 3–12 Pet-safe 0

More ways to filter

By style

By room

Frequently asked questions

Do I really need stuffed animals for these elf scenes?
These 18 ideas use stuffed animals as a key prop. Most allow substitutions — cotton balls for snow, ribbon for string, printed paper for a themed prop. Read each idea's "You'll need" list for specifics.
Where's the best place to get stuffed animals?
Most households already have stuffed animals on hand. If not, the affiliate link next to each prop in an idea's "You'll need" list goes to a Amazon search for that specific item.
Are any of these stuffed animals ideas pet safe?
Several are — check the "Pet safe" badge on individual idea cards, or use the Pet Safe filter from the main generator to narrow the list.